What tree removal actually costs in St. Paul
Size is the single biggest price driver. A small ornamental or shrubby tree in the 20-foot range might run $230 to $450. A mature elm or ash in the 50-foot range lands between $760 and $1,400. A towering cottonwood or silver maple pushing 70 to 80 feet can run $1,300 to $1,850 or more.
Beyond size, a few things push the price up or down:
- Access. A tree in an open backyard is cheaper to work than one wedged between a fence and the house. Tight access means slower work and more rigging.
- Condition. A dead or brittle tree requires more careful piece-work on the way down. That takes longer.
- Stump removal. Grinding the stump is almost always a separate line item, typically $75 to $150 depending on diameter. Get it included in the quote or ask for a separate number.
- Emerald ash borer and Dutch elm disease. St. Paul has documented pressure from both pests. If your ash or elm is already dead or compromised, removal is usually more involved. The city explicitly lists both as grounds for boulevard tree removal.
- Time of year. Winter removal can be cheaper because crews have more open schedules and frozen ground protects the lawn. Summer is peak season.
Permits and local rules
St. Paul's permit rules depend on where the tree is.
Boulevard trees (the strip between the sidewalk and the street) are city property, and the city code requires written permission before you do any work on them. The Boulevard Tree Permit covers planting, trimming, treating, stumping, and removal. The application is free. Work without it can expose you to liability and conflict with the city forester.
Private-property trees in the Tree Preservation District are a different matter. If a project involves grading, a plat, a site plan, or a building permit, and a tree 12 inches in diameter or larger is coming down, the city requires a Tree Preservation Plan. That review carries a $273 fee. If you are just removing a private-yard tree with no associated construction permit, this typically does not apply, but confirm with the city's Department of Safety and Inspections before assuming.
For a simple backyard removal with no construction project attached, most homeowners do not need a permit. Still, if the tree is near the street or you have any doubt about property lines, call 651-266-6400 (St. Paul Parks and Recreation) before the crew shows up.
How to choose a tree service in St. Paul
Get at least three quotes. Prices for the same tree can vary by several hundred dollars between crews. A low bid is not automatically a red flag, but a bid with no mention of insurance is.
Ask every company for proof of general liability insurance and workers' compensation coverage. Tree work is one of the more hazardous trades. If an uninsured crew member gets hurt in your yard, you may be liable.
Check for ISA certification. An ISA-certified arborist has passed a written exam and carries continuing education requirements. It does not guarantee perfect work, but it signals someone who takes the trade seriously.
Ask specifically how they plan to protect your lawn, fence, and any adjacent plants during the job. A good crew will answer that question without hesitation.
TreeNerd lists 18 tree care businesses serving St. Paul, including All Season's Tree Service and Snow Plowing, Birch Tree Care LLC, Canopy Tree Health, and Gold Leaf Tree Service. You can compare them and request quotes at TreeNerd.