Not every crack is the same
Surface checks in bark are common and mostly cosmetic. Bark contracts and expands with temperature swings, and shallow cracks that stay in the outer bark layer do not threaten the tree's structure. Old pruning wounds sometimes callus over with wrinkled, split-looking bark. That is normal healing.
The line between harmless and dangerous runs at the bark surface. Once a crack extends into the wood, the math changes.
The cracks that signal real trouble
Direction matters a lot. Horizontal cracks are a sign of imminent trunk failure and require attention right away. Vertical cracks that penetrate into the wood indicate structural problems and need professional inspection, even if failure is not immediate.
Failure risk goes up sharply when any of these are true:
- The crack is deep or long, or runs completely through the trunk
- Two or more cracks appear in the same area of the trunk
- The crack connects to a cavity, decay, or soft wood
- Mushrooms or shelf-like conks grow from bark near the crack
- The trunk is leaning and the soil around the base is heaving or cracking
Any single one of these warrants a call to an ISA Certified Arborist. Two or more together mean keep people and property out from under that tree until someone qualified has looked at it in person.
Included bark and split trunks
Included bark forms when two stems grow at a tight V-shaped angle, trapping bark between them instead of letting wood-to-wood attachment develop. The bark acts like a wedge. As both stems grow thicker over the years, they push outward against each other, and the union gets weaker, not stronger.
You can often spot it from the ground. Look for a tight V where two roughly equal stems rise from the same point. If the union looks pinched and bark is visible between the stems rather than a smooth collar of wood, that is likely included bark. Equal-sized, wishbone-like stems have a high probability of separating during storms, especially under wind, ice, or snow load.
A split trunk, where the stems have already begun to separate, is further along. A split trunk is likely to fail completely in a later storm. That is not speculation; it is the consistent finding from state forestry programs that study urban tree failures.
What to do next
Start with a walk around the tree at a safe distance. Look at the trunk from multiple angles. Check the base for heaving soil, fungal growth, or cracks near the roots. Note what direction any cracks run and whether they look surface-level or deeper.
TreeNerd's free tree-check tool lets you describe what you see and get a quick read on whether the signs point to something urgent or something to watch.
For anything that looks deep, horizontal, or involves a split stem or included bark union, stop there and contact a certified arborist. Photos help, but an in-person evaluation is the only way to actually assess the risk. No one can tell you a specific tree is safe from a description alone.